Yes, I'm chiming in. (As if you expected anything else). Part of the reason I'm hesitant in "defending Pixar" is because lots of other people have done so already, and far more eloquently than I think I could. But I'll take a crack at it, because this is a place I'm so fond of, and I have a lot to say.
Let me start off by saying there are four kinds of people. The first kind are those who, when hearing about
Finding Dory on twitter yesterday, responded less than enthusiastically. They're not crazy about the idea, but they're not losing faith in Luxo. (And they weren't ever). The second kind are those who have been
cheerfully skeptical about this movie since it was "announced" last summer, and when the news broke, they were somewhat surprised but not all that concerned, and will support the film and its director. And since I of course belong to this second group, I have to say that I didn't care too much, but I liked what I read of the
synopsis. The third kind are those who apparently have been waiting for this sequel for the past
10 years??? ("I plan on pushing kids out of my way when this comes out," etc.) The fourth kind are those who are now convinced this is the final nail in the coffin, that Pixar has officially sold out and will continue to do so, sequels are the worst, Pixar has never done a good sequel in the past so they can't possibly do one now, ugh
Cars 2 and
Brave are so terrible, now
Finding Dory?!, now more sequels, how could you do this Pixar, I remember the good ol' days when you were making Listerine commercials, how could you do this to
me?!
And then there's Ellen Degeneres, who has been the most passionate supporter of a
Nemo sequel. A lot of us wished she wasn't...but her joy is really infectious. She loves Dory! And although Dory provides comic relief, she's also a profoundly sad character. It's wonderful because she is both vulnerable and silly, and according to Andrew Stanton, she also represents a spiritual dimension of the film.
"Dory was, literally, an angel fish. 'The
protagonist’s battle was to overcome fear by discovering faith, and
certainly Dory represented the angel, or the helper who showed him how
to let go and not be consumed by his worries.'" (The Pixar Touch).
There's a lot to Dory, and the idea of finding out why she was all alone, and being reunited with her family is a tantalizing one. I can't "lose faith in Pixar", because they're always committed to story, and when they find a good one, it's a good one. We can continue to be skeptical, but to borrow another cliche, we can only wait and see. Kyle actually sums it up excellently in his
post.
I should mention that there is also a fifth kind of person. This one doesn't see the need for a sequel to any Pixar film, will fervently criticize Pixar for daring to make sequels in the first place (what was the reaction back in 1999 when
Toy Story 2 was taken over by John Lasseter in order to prevent Disney from cashing in on it by making it a mediocre direct to video product?), and believes that if Pixar is going to make sequels, the one that needs to happen is an
Incredibles 2. They don't seem to realize the hypocrisy. Maybe the people who want a sequel to
The Incredibles are also excited about
Finding Dory. But there are people who prefer a sequel to the Parr story, while also sneering at Pixar's other sequels.
Here is one of the reasons Pixar is so great. They make movies they want to see. They don't follow trends. And they especially don't take their cues from fickle audiences. While a sequel to
The Incredibles would be logical to some people, Pixar surprises everyone by instead expanding on the
Nemo universe. I don't want a sequel to
The Incredibles (it's one of my north stars however!), but I believe if Brad Bird can come up with a story just as fantastic as the first, then it will be worth it. Kind of like Andrew Stanton with his idea for Dory.
No matter what the people at Pixar decide to do, let's remember that they are people. They're allowed to make mistakes. Could they fail? Of course. If
Cars 2 and
Brave are missteps, then they're fabulous ones. That's definitely not enough to write the studio off, which has plenty more stories and characters to introduce us to, or different stories for the ones we love. The way people jump on bandwagons is so funny, and just a bit infuriating. Is it because they had such a long winning streak that some negative opinions and reviews are proof they're no longer one of the best film studios out there? No, no it is not. I like to imagine, if John Lasseter and the rest of them paid attention to any of those bloggers predicting (hoping for?) Pixar's demise, to be laughing over the fuss being made, even if it is negative. "Sweet music," as Doc Hudson would say.
Pixar has many more years, and I look forward to cheering them on.